Poverty After Poverty Reduction: Living Just Above Survival

by | 20 Nov 2026

“Factory workers producing shirts at Sleek Garment Export, in Accra, Ghana” by World Bank Photo Collection, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Over recent years, some of the most important critical work on poverty has begun with a deceptively simple proposition: poverty is not simply something that happens. It is produced.

Susan Marks gave this insight one of its most powerful formulations through the idea of “planned misery”. Misery, in this account, belongs to the logic of socio-economic and legal arrangements, including those whose participants understand themselves to be doing ordinary, even beneficial, things. This analytical move matters because it shifts attention towards the relations through which some people become secure while others remain exposed. More recently, Tu Phuong Nguyen has explored the mutually reinforcing relationship between law and precarity, showing through everyday experiences in Vietnam how attempts to secure livelihoods through law can themselves reproduce insecurity.

Jason Beckett pushed this line of argument directly into international law. Poverty, he argued, is created, maintained and regulated; indeed, poverty is a legal regime. Wealth and poverty must therefore be understood relationally, a point also emphasised by Branwen Gruffydd Jones. John Linarelli, Margot Salomon and Muthucumaraswamy Sornarajah have subsequently described what they call the “legal rendering of immiseration”: an international order in which law helps constitute the conditions it later encounters as poverty requiring correction. For them, this is precisely the misery of international law.

These critical arguments have sat uncomfortably alongside the mainstream language of poverty reduction over the previous decades. Development institutions have continued to ask how poverty can be measured, how many people have escaped it, which interventions work, and how the poor might be incorporated into labour markets, the digital and green transitions and, more recently, of course, AI. As Guilherme Cabral and I have recently argued, even the growing recognition of poverty as a multidimensional condition linked to human rights has often been absorbed into technocratic systems of measurement and management that leave its structural causes largely untouched. Critical scholarship has therefore kept returning to a prior question: how is poverty produced in the first place?

From Critique to Recognition

Yet something interesting happened in 2026.

Olivier De Schutter’s final report as UN Special Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty and Human Rights, The Manufacturing of Poverty, advances a proposition familiar to critical scholars: poverty is manufactured through institutional choices concerning labour, wealth, care and markets. Eradicating it therefore requires changing those arrangements. The accompanying Roadmap for Eradicating Poverty Beyond Growth, developed with contributions from UN agencies, governments, trade unions, social movements, academics and civil society, proposes changes to labour and care, public services, ecological governance and the international economic order. Presented at the International Labour Organization in Geneva in April 2026, it was subsequently brought before the Human Rights Council.

This intervention has its own history within the UN.

Philip Alston, De Schutter’s predecessor, had already challenged prevailing assumptions through his criticism of neoliberal policies and examination of international financial institutions and social protection.

None of this new institutional endorsement means, however, that critical arguments have suddenly become international orthodoxy; powerful interests oppose many of the Roadmap’s proposals. Still, a proposition advanced by critical scholars for decades is now being clearly and powerfully articulated from within the institutions whose assumptions they have so persistently questioned.

Living Just Above Survival

But what does poverty look like today? And what does its international and institutional production mean when the state, ultimately expected to address it, is itself undergoing significant transformations?

My own work has increasingly led me to approach these questions through the condition of living just above survival – captured also in Spanish expressions such as vivir pelado, raspando la olla, vivir al día, or, in English, being skint, scraping by, living hand to mouth, struggling to make ends meet and living on the breadline.

These expressions carry different histories, but speak to a familiar global experience: making available resources stretch a little further, knowing that even a modest disruption might make tomorrow more difficult than today.

This concern does not diminish the still enormous challenge of extreme poverty, or the well-documented reduction in extreme poverty in recent decades. Rather, it draws attention to a much larger population whose living conditions have improved, sometimes considerably, without acquiring the security needed to sustain those improvements.

The extraordinary decline in extreme poverty is real and matters, particularly given China’s contribution. Yet the categories through which this achievement is narrated obscure the conditions emerging alongside it. Under the World Bank’s revised international poverty lines, extreme poverty means living on less than US$3.00 per day in 2021 purchasing power parity (PPP). The Bank also uses US$4.20 and US$8.30 thresholds for lower-middle-income and upper-middle-income countries.

Move beyond these thresholds, though, still to relatively modest levels of income or consumption, and a different world appears.

In 2024, approximately 53% of humanity lived on less than US$10 per day, and 81% on less than US$30, according to estimates drawn from the World Bank’s Poverty and Inequality Platform, expressed in 2021 PPP dollars. These are not universal definitions of poverty. They do, however, expose the distance between escaping extreme poverty and acquiring economic security, including in societies conventionally classified as wealthy.

What concerns me, then, is this vast population living just above survival, between destitution and durable security. People may consume more, enjoy better services and experience genuine improvements while remaining vulnerable to disruption. An illness, a rent increase, the loss of a job, care responsibilities, a flood or a land dispute that refuses to end can undo years of hard-won improvement.

Their position on a statistical distribution may have changed. They may have escaped extreme poverty, moved closer to the US$10 benchmark, or even crossed it, while everyday life remains organised around managing insecurity.

I am reminded of this again and again by families whose lives I have followed for decades now, and who sometimes describe their circumstances through a Colombian saying: cuando el pobre saca la ropa a secar, llueve (when the poor hang their clothes out to dry, it rains). Poverty is a condition that constantly chases them, returning to bite again and again with relentless force, both within their lifetimes and across generations.

What matters in this context, and for this population, then, is the infrastructure holding people marginally above survival, and its capacity to keep them afloat or help them move forward: wages, public services, remittances, debt, informal work, family labour, welfare payments, housing arrangements and increasingly digitised social protection. These arrangements sustain life, often precariously, amid enormous global inequalities.

Governing Poverty, Sustaining Insecurity

And here is why the contemporary state matters so much.

After decades in which neoliberalism supposedly displaced the state, the state is visibly back. Governments subsidise industries, manage energy transitions, build digital infrastructures, operate social registries and intervene in financial markets. Yet, as Ilias Alami and Adam Dixon explore, this renewed embrace of state intervention has preserved the centrality of markets and private accumulation. Green industrial policy, for example, increasingly involves de-risking private investment with public resources.

We might understand these developments as distinctive, if peculiar, features of what has long been emerging as the new developmental state, especially from the perspective of populations living just above survival.

The older developmental imagination, whatever its exclusions, contradictions and violence, was oriented towards structural transformation. As I have explored elsewhere, industrialisation, formal employment, rising wages and public provision were expected to absorb populations into greater security, even as international inequalities constrained postcolonial states. That promise was never realised for much of the world. As James Ferguson and Tania Murray Li argued, the expectation that development would eventually deliver everyone a “proper job” was once central to this vision, but has increasingly faded, if not disappeared altogether.

The new developmental state, as I have been exploring with colleagues over recent years, intervenes extensively, but with a different horizon of incorporation (here and here).

It targets populations with extraordinary precision, transfers modest payments, subsidises investment and insures private risk. Yet these capacities coexist with limited commitments, and often limited possibilities, to guarantee livelihoods, universalise public provision or discipline concentrated economic power. As Lena Lavinas shows, contemporary welfare arrangements can incorporate poorer households into financial circuits while leaving the distribution of resources largely untouched.

There is something revealing about this distribution of state capacities. Governments can currently devote enormous resources to attracting investment, protecting financial stability and creating markets, while treating economic security for their populations as expensive and administratively complex – whether because of debt pressures, the priorities of regressive elites in power, or both. As a result, the capacity to administer poverty has expanded, while the possibilities for transforming the relations producing it remain constrained by the global organisation of production, finance, property and labour. For vast populations, development is the management of a life just above survival.

Poverty and the Everyday

It is against this background that I would like to introduce three contributions from members of the Global Poverty and the 21st Century research group at La Trobe Law School. These contributions, which will appear as part of this Critical Legal Thinking series, approach poverty from different locations, but each explores how legal arrangements participate in producing insecurity in everyday life.

Apoorva Sharma’s “Finding the Minimum Wage in the Heart of the Professional Managerial Class Empire” begins with the difficulty of saying something that ought to be obvious. If a minimum wage establishes a legal minimum, what does it mean when it cannot secure a minimum standard of living? Comparing Australia and India, Apoorva asks why scholarship can make it so difficult to articulate material truths about labour that workers have long understood, whether in wealthy Australia or postcolonial India. His contribution also asks how the demand for ever-greater academic nuance can obscure elementary questions about global exploitation.

Andréia Aguiar Paranaguá’s “Gender Poverty: Everyday Reproductive Governance” brings us into the regulation of bodies and futures through the on-the-ground dynamics of access to lawful abortion for often racialised, low-income girls and women. Studying access to lawful abortion in Tocantins, Brazil, she shows how poverty passes through legal rules, hospital protocols, information, transport, administrative discretion and what she calls everyday reproductive power brokers. These arrangements shape whose choices remain possible and whose futures are narrowed by forced maternity, interrupted education, exclusion from employment and the costs of obtaining – or being denied – care.

Finally, Md Atiqur Rahman’s “Disputing Poverty: Land Litigation, Extraction and Delay in Bangladesh” takes us into law’s sedimented history. Drawing on his years as a judge, Atiqur describes Bangladesh’s land regime as a colonial palimpsest, where successive reforms leave earlier arrangements intact. The state can register transfers and extract revenue while remaining unable, and above all unwilling, to settle ownership conclusively. Delay, therefore, distributes value: those able to sustain litigation across generations gain an advantage over families who cannot afford to wait. Poverty emerges through the encounter with law itself.

Beyond Poverty Voyeurism

What I find particularly compelling about these three contributions is that they approach poverty through institutions rarely understood primarily as instruments of impoverishment. Equally importantly, their subjects are not necessarily those whom decades of poverty voyeurism have taught us to recognise as poor, and therefore deserving of attention because of their extreme conditions of destitution. The subjects at the heart of their concerns are workers struggling to make a living, girls and women navigating reproductive regulation, and families seeking secure claims to land.

Minimum wage regulation is supposed to protect workers. Healthcare systems are supposed to protect bodily autonomy and well-being. Property registration and judicial reform are supposed to provide security and justice. Yet each contribution asks what these institutions actually do in their particular historical circumstances, and whose interests and futures they serve in a world in which 81% of humanity survives on less than US$30 per day.

This is again why the institutional recognition that poverty is manufactured matters. It invites us to examine how law distributes security and insecurity, including among people whose lives do not resemble familiar images of extreme deprivation. The Roadmap offers an opportunity to pursue these questions internationally. For those living just above survival, however, they are already encountered daily: in the wage that does not stretch far enough, the healthcare that remains inaccessible, or the legal dispute that consumes a family’s resources.

These ordinary encounters with law are where the contemporary organisation of poverty becomes visible, and where the difficult work of changing it must begin, even as that work also demands confronting the larger capitalist scaffolding of the present.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

POSTS BY EMAIL

Join 5,008 other subscribers

We respect your privacy.

Fair Access Publisher
(pay what you can, free option available) 

↓ just published ↓

PUBLISH ON CLT

Publish your article with us and get read by the largest community of critical legal scholars, with over 4500 subscribers.

Latest Articles

Broken laws. Popular resistance.

Broken laws. Popular resistance.

“You are killing me. You are killing me”, Paul screamed. And they did, in fact, twice. First of all, they killed his physical body and then the usual narrative of blaming the victim killed him again [...] the collusion started at that very point and carried on…

read more