Finding the Minimum Wage in the Heart of the Professional Managerial Class Empire

by | 21 Nov 2026

“Factory workers producing shirts at Sleek Garment Export, in Accra, Ghana” by World Bank Photo Collection, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

The minimum wage is a state mandated lower limit on wages that can be paid to any employee in the jurisdiction of the state. This governmental lower limit on wages effectively sets a living standard. This standard is heavily implied (but not actually guaranteed) to be above the poverty line.  Simultaneously, the modern minimum wage now faces the global cost-of-living crisis. As prices increase, the minimum wage struggles to keep pace, resulting in a fall in the living standard.  

This leads to a strange contradiction. By definition, if wages are not keeping pace with the cost of living, the standard of living is falling. Yet the minimum wage exists to set and maintain a standard of living. The relationship between the two is therefore existential. If the cost-of-living crisis exists, the minimum wage is failing to serve its purpose. If the minimum wage standard is effective, a cost-of-living crisis cannot occur.

My initial approach to analysing this was to look at the minimum wage systems in the country with the lowest minimum wage in the world, India, alongside the country with the highest minimum wage in the world, Australia. The purpose of this exercise was not to compare the countries’ systems but instead to see if having a high or low minimum wage would at least guarantee the standard of living inherent to a minimum wage law. Equally, as is increasingly empirically verifiable, if both these systems are failing to maintain a standard of living, what is a minimum wage really for?

Unfortunately, this approach has forced me into an even larger conflict, this time with academia itself.

Postmodern methodologies

In 2014, David Graeber coined the term “vulgar foucauldianism” to describe the dangers of postmodern scholarship. He argued that postmodernism’s rejection of absolute truths is part of a larger campaign to obfuscate the fact that capitalism, and in particular neoliberal capitalism, exists to transfer wealth from workers to the owners of the means of production. Specifically, he argued that the university, through its use of postmodern philosophies, “…enshrine[s] the particular class experiences of the professional-managerial class as universal truths…”.

This is in part due to the unique role of universities in the class struggle. A college degree is marketed as the best way to move from a blue-collar physically intensive job to a relatively comfortable and well-paid white-collar one. If a student fails to get a good job in their field and is instead forced to work in a physically demanding (and often minimum wage) job, the media  reports on it as a tragedy. Simultaneously, business owners, being employers, are always welcome in the university environment. Mark Zuckerberg gave the commencement address at Harvard in 2017 even though he had dropped out of the same institution and has no college degree.

All of this is exacerbated by the actions of University faculty. Receiving grants, often from employers, is seen as a career success. Similarly, professors often provide consultancy services to the private sector. Such positions are often institutionalised such as Oxford University Innovation (self-described as the innovation partner of the University of Oxford) which offers step-by-step guidance for how academics can become consultants. On the other hand, advocating for labour rights can significantly hinder career advancement. The best example of this is Graeber himself who was sacked from Yale due to his political beliefs and advocacy. Graeber had stated that this happened due to his defence of a graduate student who was facing expulsion for her union organising.

The chilling effect of these inherently financial incentives have been subsumed into postmodern and critical scholarship’s love for pedantry. Broad claims about the nature of the economy, of labour extraction or even global imperialism are too simplistic to be correct. Instead, the world can only be understood from the perspective of a ‘grain of sand’ which allows every experience and global trend to be individually siloed away. It is possible to ‘gesture’ at larger trends in your research but to state them clearly and definitively is unprofessional and imprecise.

Speaking truth to pedants

The biggest challenge I have faced with my research has therefore been to state simple truths plainly in an environment obsessed with complexity. An example of this was my claim that the Australian minimum wage is inherently technocratic. The Australian minimum wage is set by an “expert panel” of the Fair Work Commission and the Fair Work Act, 2009 which governs the setting of the minimum wage even specifies the technical qualifications necessary to be considered an “expert” for this panel. Serving members of this expert panel are often themselves professors which again emphasises the role of the university in the labour law process. Nonetheless, stating plainly that this meets the most stringent dictionary definition of technocracy is seen as reductionist and lacking nuance. I have had to devote huge amounts of time, energy and wordcount to defending what is effectively a stated fact in the law itself.

This pushback has generated a type of paranoia about other parts of my work. Will there be questions about my claim that the minimum wage is inherently bureaucratic even though the creation of a specialised bureaucracy to set and enforce the minimum wage is also defined in the law?  If so, what evidence would be enough to satisfy? Every such claim therefore drives me into an obsessive hunt for ‘secondary literature’ which states the obvious. In this environment, reality is defined by previously published papers. The law is subordinate to the opinions of other academics.

The need to silo away research is another challenge for my chosen jurisdictions. Australia is a developed country with a high standard of living and a small population. India is a developing country with a low standard of living and the largest population in the world. My choice of these vastly differing case studies is intentional. The cost-of-living crisis is common to both, even though they each have a long history of the enforcement of a minimum wage law. The purpose of conducting these case studies in vastly different jurisdictions is to isolate the effect of the cost-of-living crisis and the efficacy of the minimum wage systems in countering it. If neither a ‘strong’ minimum wage which sets a high standard of living nor a ‘weak’ minimum wage which cleaves closely to the poverty line are effective, it suggests that there is a deep and fundamental flaw in the overall minimum wage system which transcends jurisdiction.

Regardless, I am constantly advised to drop my study of either India or Australia to manage scope. Following this advice would render the purpose of my methodology redundant as it would prevent me from pointing out that both ‘strong’ and ‘weak’ minimum wage systems suffer the same crisis of affordability. However, this advice is designed to account for the ‘uniqueness’ and ‘complexity’ of each of these systems. The idea that there may be a commonality of experience or even worse solidarity between workers in India and Australia exceeds the limits of postmodernism.

This is not to say that there is no ‘uniqueness’ or ‘complexity’ in the Indian and Australian systems of course, there definitely is. The problem comes from the insistence that two jurisdictions both committed to free market capitalism in an increasingly globalised economy would have nothing in common. Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet.

A wholly inappropriate ‘gesture’ at the failure of postmodernism in studying labour

Labour law, including the minimum wage, is governed at the domestic level with each country sporting a radically complex and bespoke set of laws. These laws are constantly in a state of flux through regular amendments and enforcement as a result of changes in governments with different ideological priorities. Even the minimum wage laws that I have been studying are subject to fundamental changes. In May 2026, the Indian government announced it was entirely scrapping the criteria it has used to set the minimum wage since 1957. Fully describing these laws with the requisite historical and socio-political context is an exercise in futility.

Worse, labour activists have long since known that labour laws and state power have been used to forcibly extract labour from workers using the veneer of legalism. Writing in 1903, Eugene Debs argued that “The class in power in modern civilized nations, the capitalists, rule in their own interest and to this end the courts, the army and navy, the militia and police, the school and church, in short, all departments of government and all social institutions are simply the branches and offshoots of the tree of capitalism that is rooted in class ownership of the resources of life.”

Similarly, Upendra Baxi has claimed that labour law in India is itself the tool by which employers carry out primitive accumulation. He argued that these labour laws, even if they have text within them to benefit workers, are selectively enforced by the state to benefit employers and punish workers, a phenomenon he called “private legislation”.

These broad claims by Debs and Baxi far exceed the permissible claims made under postmodernist methodologies. Debs’ assertion that every single governmental and social institution is inimical to workers would be challenged by numerous anecdotal examples of judgments by courts which benefit workers. Interestingly, Debs seemed to be aware of this line of argument even in 1903. He stated: “The lower courts, dependent directly upon the popular vote, are moved to vary the program with an occasional “glad hand” to labor, but if there is any substance in such an “off” decision it is quickly snatched away by the Supreme Court, to which it is always appealed in the full confidence that the higher tribunal, far above the sway of popular passion, will quickly set aside the ruling of the inferior court, that there may be no friction between the capitalist machine and its judicial functions.” Given the recent record of the US Supreme Court, he may as well have been describing the present day.

Reclaiming solidarity in the hyper-individualised university environment

The individualisation of labour struggles and their reduction to isolated strikes or protests detract from the overall story of capitalist exploitation. They do not give a full account of the far reaching, totalising and global effects of the single-minded pursuit for profit that is the foundational principle of capitalism. Applying this to my own research on the minimum wage, strikes and other industrial actions for a higher minimum wage have the same demands whether they occur in the developed global North or the developing global South. However, stating this directly runs into the brick wall of hyper-individual post-modernism.

So here it is necessary to return to Graeber’s original point that postmodern approaches have resulted in the experiences of the working class being removed from the university environment. Studying and researching in the university environment while not easy is not physically demanding or dangerous. A university professor does not ordinarily run the risk of losing life or limb to heavy machinery accidents. A university student, even in the most stringent of academic environments, is not subject to the constant surveillance of an Amazon delivery driver.

Consequently, the study of labour becomes the study of the ‘other’ and the language of labour law becomes indistinguishable from that of human rights. This is because labour and wage struggles are as remote an experience to an academic as human rights abuse. Genocide, the imposition of famine and state repression do not occur in the civilised environs of the university. They happen to other people.

The most jarring example of this depersonalisation of issues comes from my own personal experience of talking to Western scholars about state repression and the possibility of being arrested for sharing certain views. These scholars reacted with shock and fear, as though I were discussing self-harm. However, my own labour law professor in India, a Marxist and trade unionist, simply said “It is important to be arrested at least once in life. How else would you know how it feels?”

Ultimately, the study of labour is the study of class struggle and violence. Until critical scholarship moves towards a materialist and structuralist approach and away from the rhetorical and discursive, it will never be able to study labour.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

POSTS BY EMAIL

Join 5,008 other subscribers

We respect your privacy.

Fair Access Publisher
(pay what you can, free option available) 

↓ just published ↓

PUBLISH ON CLT

Publish your article with us and get read by the largest community of critical legal scholars, with over 4500 subscribers.

Latest Articles

Broken laws. Popular resistance.

Broken laws. Popular resistance.

“You are killing me. You are killing me”, Paul screamed. And they did, in fact, twice. First of all, they killed his physical body and then the usual narrative of blaming the victim killed him again [...] the collusion started at that very point and carried on…

read more