Gender Poverty: Everyday Reproductive Governance

by | 22 Nov 2026

“Factory workers producing shirts at Sleek Garment Export, in Accra, Ghana” by World Bank Photo Collection, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

All over the globe, reproductive health and rights are in constant dispute. In recent years, it has been possible to notice a major shift in some countries toward advanced recognition and access to reproductive rights (e.g. Argentina, Ireland and Colombia’s decriminalisation of abortion; access to abortion becoming a constitutional right in France), yet, in other countries, those rights have been rolled back (e.g. the United States Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade and, consequently, removing protections for abortion rights). In this encounter, how can everyday local actors’ actions shape, control and deny access to abortion services for low-income women?

A Global Issue

The UNFPA’s 2025 State of World Population report shows that many people are still unable to exercise their reproductive rights, especially those from disadvantaged and marginalised groups. The report identifies economic precarity, unequal access to healthcare and contraception, sexual violence, and restrictive abortion laws as some of the main barriers to full reproductive agency,1 showing that legal changes are not equal to practical access and that reproductive rights access also depends on a person being able to obtain information and contraception, healthcare, financial and emotional support, transport, and freedom from coercion.

On this broader reproductive rights framework, abortion is a key point of concern and dispute with high consequences for marginalised groups. The UNFPA’s 2025 report presents some worrying effects linked to abortion bans and restrictions, for example, the increasing rates of maternal disability and mortality caused by unsafe abortions, and the production of cycles of poverty, especially among adolescent mothers who end up dropping out of school, leading to incomplete education and undermining access to the labour force.

One Step Forward, Two Steps Back

Latin America has been leading the debate around abortion law reform in recent years. In the context of the Green Wave, which resulted from a national campaign for free, safe and legal abortion organised by feminist movements in Argentina, three countries from the region have decriminalised abortion: Argentina (2020), Colombia (2022) and Mexico (2021 and 2023).

In an analysis of previous abortion law reforms in the region in the context of Latin America’s ‘Pink Tide’, a wave of left-wing and centre-left governments elected across Latin America in the early 2000s, political scientists Blofield and Ewig (2017) argue that although a left-wing government creates a favourable political opening for reform, this alone is not sufficient. They list other factors that made legal change possible, such as feminist mobilisation, the level of secularisation, favourable public opinion supported by the media, supportive healthcare professionals, and sympathetic religious actors. The lack of some (or all) factors in some countries of the region justifies why abortion access in the region remains uneven: it is legalised in some countries (e.g. Uruguay), and under restrictive laws (e.g. Brazil) or even total bans (e.g. El Salvador) in others.

In the opposite direction, the past years have also shown that Latin America is becoming the stage of a growing anti-abortion activism that has considerably increased into a broader anti-gender alliance, with strong opposition to abortion, resistance to sex education in schools, LGBTQIAPN+ rights, and gender-equality policies, forming a countermovement in reaction to feminist mobilisation and policy advances.

As shown by Machado, Peñas-Defago and Gianella Malca (2022), the anti-abortion mobilisation field in Latin America has changed, expanding from the historical Catholic Church’s opposition to include networks and alliances with Evangelical churches, politicians, parliamentary caucuses, pro-life and pro-family NGOs, lawyers, doctors, bioethics institutes, and transnational organisations. With this broader set of actors, the strategies and mechanisms applied have also changed. For example, anti-abortion actors have become more active in electoral and political parties, and their arguments on religious and moral grounds (e.g. abortion is a sin) have been reduced to include the use of scientific, legal, constitutional, and human-rights language (e.g. right to life from conception of the foetus). These changes in actors and strategies are circulating transnationally in the region at different levels, adapting to each country and local realities.

Abortion on Paper: Brazil’s Context

In Brazil’s legal framework, abortion is criminalised by the 1940 Penal Code, with only two exemptions allowing women and girls to access abortion through the country’s health system (i.e. when there is no other way to save the pregnant person’s life and in pregnancies resulting from rape). Feminist activists have successfully fought for the expansion of this framework in the judicial arena to permit abortion in cases of anencephalic foetuses. Still, other attempts through the judiciary to uphold fundamental rights listed in the Constitution, including the rights to health, dignity, and equality, aiming to further abortion service access, have remained without a solution. At the same time, attacks on abortion laws from the legislative arena, where the shift towards far-right ideologies is more prominent, have become increasingly frequent. This reflects what Machado, Peñas-Defago, and Gianella Malca (2022) describe as the expansion of anti-abortion mobilisation.

AzMina’s 2026 monitoring of Brazil’s Congress activities, where abortion and LGBTQIAPN+ rights have become central targets of the anti-gender agenda, confirms the expansion of anti-abortion and anti-gender mobilisations on the legislative arena: 2,036 gender-related bills introduced between January 2023 and April 2026, 83% more than the previous legislative term. An emblematic example is the Law Proposal 1904/2024 (PL 1904/2024) that aims to classify every abortion after 22 weeks of pregnancy as homicide, including those performed under the three existing exemptions. In most cases, abortion and LGBTQIAPN+ rights are framed in these law proposals as threats to the ‘traditional family,’ children, religion, and social morality.

In the meantime, people from socio-economically marginalised backgrounds face exacerbated challenges accessing ‘legal abortion,2 including the need to travel long distances to access abortion services in the cases exempted by law, the illegal request of a police report and/or judicial authorisation by hospitals to access such services and the use of outdated and unsafe methods to terminate unwanted pregnancies when ‘legal abortion’ is not a feasible option.

Local Actions, Long-Term Consequences

In my research, I am trying to understand this interaction between access to abortion, socio-economic marginalisation and backlash on reproductive rights by focusing on the state of Tocantins, Brazil, particularly in relation to the rightward turn in the country and across Latin America as a whole. For this purpose, I examine barriers to accessing legal abortion, its unequal socio-economic effects on women and girls from socio-economically marginalised backgrounds, and how national and local actors are shaping the everyday negotiation and (lack of) delivery of abortion services in the state. I approach this by utilising the concept of ‘reproductive governance’ coined by the anthropologists Lynn Morgan and Elizabeth Roberts (2012), which describes how state and non-state actors shape and regulate reproductive behaviour through legal, political, economic, and moral mechanisms. 

Through the lens of reproductive governance, it is possible to explain the interaction between different aspects of access to legal abortion, going beyond government and legislation to include public policies, hospital protocols, funding, moral discourse, religion, lobbying, information access, and advocacy (among others), and all people involved in these areas of knowledge and activities, to provide a pathway to comprehend how new laws, social movements, economy and morality are working over reproductive bodies.

The case study for my research is the state of Tocantins. Tocantins was created with the promulgation of the 1988 Constitution of Brazil, separating what was considered the north and south of the state of Goiás, with a promise of economic and social development for its people. Nevertheless, today there are still prevalent socioeconomic disparities amongst Tocantins’ diverse population, which includes Indigenous people, ‘quilombolas’,3 and both impoverished and affluent, urban and rural communities. Regardless of their diversity, people in Tocantins have repeatedly voted for conservative politicians who defend the interests of agribusiness and promote an agenda that is socially conservative and economically liberal, making Tocantins one of the centres of the well-known right-wing backlash experienced in Brazil since the mid-2010s. This backlash has had a significant further impact on how abortion is accessed, understood and practised in Tocantins.

With a population of approximately 1.6 million people and comprising 139 municipalities, Tocantins have one of the higher rates of sexual violence in the country. According to the 2026 Brazilian Public Security Yearbook, in 2025, Tocantins recorded 57.2 cases of sexual violence per 100,000 children and adolescents, compared with the national rate of 9.6 cases. Nevertheless, only one hospital in the entire state provides ‘legal abortion’ services. According to data collected during the fieldwork phase of my research between November 2025 and February 2026, only 24 abortion procedures were performed last year.

In my research, I look to this regional context and argue that reproductive governance is being shaped on the ground by local, and more often than not conservative, actors with the power to facilitate access to abortion services (e.g. Child Protection Council members, the Federal Medical Council, healthcare providers and the Court of Justice) but who refuse to do so for a large range of reasons. These, as I identify them in my research, everyday reproductive power brokers – individuals or organisations occupying an intermediary position connecting people to their reproductive rights – aggravate existing institutional barriers, disseminate limited or inaccurate information, and exacerbate administrative obstacles, which leads to inconsistent implementation of the legal framework for those who seek and need abortion services.

These reflect structural conditions that restrict access to legal abortion in the state of Tocantins. For example, abortion services permitted by law in cases of sexual violence, with no mention of the other legal exemptions, were only regulated by Ordinance 372/2026/SES/GASEC4 in the state in August of this year.

This late regulation and lack of information on the other exemptions create an environment that allows control over people’s reproduction through deliberate ambiguity, providing excuses (or mechanisms) for actors (or reproductive power brokers) on the ground to deny complete access to legal abortion or hinder it, resulting in a direct and negative impact on the lives of women and girls who need abortion services, perpetuating, in particular, poverty, forced maternity and exclusion from the labour market.

Transnational Patterns in loco

By maintaining the focus on a specific regional setting, my ongoing research on access to ‘legal abortion’ and the different actors and mechanisms in place allows me to examine how wider dynamics are lived and negotiated on the ground by everyday reproductive power brokers and what their practical impact is on people’s lives. Tocantins, in this regard, is one place from which Latin America and Brazil’s story on access to abortion can be analysed and understood.

The story of women in Tocantins makes visible the uneven results of the criminalisation of abortion and how these results are most felt by women and girls from socio-economically marginalised backgrounds. Centring my research on the experiences of women and people linked to access to ‘legal abortion’ locally, it is possible to move the abortion debate from legal controversy happening in congresses, courts and the media. It directs attention to the everyday local actors and institutions whose actions shape reproductive governance locally, but with a long-term effect on the lives of those who have their reproductive rights reduced.

1The UNFPA’s 2025 State of World Population report define ‘reproductive agency’ as the “capacity to exercise informed, empowered decision-making over one’s reproduction. This capacity requires more than an ability to say yes or no; it requires an enabling environment in which individuals and couples can make choices unfettered by legal, political, economic and normative constraints. It is a fundamental aspect of bodily autonomy, self-determination and human rights; international human rights frameworks recognize reproductive agency as essential for gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls.”, UNFPA. 2025. The Real Fertility Crisis: The Pursuit of Reproductive Agency in a Changing World, State of World Population 2025. New York: United Nations Population Fund.

2‘Legal abortion’ is a common expression used in society, legislation, public policy, healthcare protocols and legal scholarship in Brazil to describe the cases three exemptions in which abortion is permitted by law/lawful abortion.  

3Ethnic-racial groups that self-identify as such, share a distinct historical trajectory, maintain specific territorial relationships, and are presumed to have African ancestry linked to their historical resistance to oppression.

4Ordinance No. 372/2026/SES/GASEC was published in the State Official Gazette No. 7,042, establishing the provision of abortion services in cases of sexual violence as permitted by law at the state level.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

POSTS BY EMAIL

Join 5,009 other subscribers

We respect your privacy.

Fair Access Publisher
(pay what you can, free option available) 

↓ just published ↓

PUBLISH ON CLT

Publish your article with us and get read by the largest community of critical legal scholars, with over 4500 subscribers.

Latest Articles

Broken laws. Popular resistance.

Broken laws. Popular resistance.

“You are killing me. You are killing me”, Paul screamed. And they did, in fact, twice. First of all, they killed his physical body and then the usual narrative of blaming the victim killed him again [...] the collusion started at that very point and carried on…

read more